443 State Route 17B, Monticello NY 12701


Interested? Call (845) 707-5274, email us, or use our form

Over 8.5 acres on State Route 17B also know as "Woodstock Way". "This property was once known at the Star Mountain Hotel in Monticello during the Catskill's heydays in the 50's and 60's. In the 90's it was converted into a charming farm market called "Lilly's." It is now time to pass the torch to a new generation with new, fresh ideas! The property consists of main building, a 2-story, 130 year old barn-style building, walk-in cooler, bathroom, hardwood floors, knotty pine walls and ceilings, with 3 driveways, well house. Approx. 484 ft. Road frontage on State Route 17B and additional 640 ft. road frontage on Maplewood Rd. There are 2 driven wells, septic (work needed on the fields), sewage system in registered with NYS SPDES program, designed to eliminate the pollution of New York waters and to maintain the highest quality of water possible. Systems need updates but the space and location are remarkable. Located on State Route 17B, this is a high traffic and highly visible location. With your own creativity and vision the possibilities are endless. (*brewery, boutique hotel, restaurant, farm market, art studio, music venue, etc.) Close to Bethel Woods Center for the Performing Arts, Dancing Cat Distillery and on the way to Western Sullivan Counties weekend attractions and destinations including the brand new Eldred Preserve opening this year! Nearby are Eldred, Narrowsburg, Barryville, Callicoon on the Delaware and other weekend destinations to explore. The weekend/tourist traffic is high in addition to the normal daily traffic. Also close to Lake Superior State Park, White Lake, Kartrite Water Park, Resorts World Casino and so much more. *pending town planning board approvals.

General Information:

MLS#: 6090940

Sq ft:

Lot: 0.00 acres

Type: Mixed Use

Zoning: Commercial 1

Down Payment:
Map this property
The Sullivan Buzz - The Lowdown on a Town

More information


Construction: Frame




Water: See Remarks, Private

Water Heater: Electric Stand Alone

Sewer: Septic Tank

Heating: Other, None

Heating Zones:

Air Conditioning: None



Tax and Fee Information

Tax Amount: $6,075

Tax Assessed Value:

443 State Route 17B
Monticello, NY 12701
Monticello School District

Contact Our Agent

Charles Petersheim
Listing courtesy of Jean Dermer
©2024 Sullivan County Multiple Listing Service (SCMLS). The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes from Multiple Listing Service of The Sullivan County Board of Realtors and the Broker Reciprocity Program. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Lazy Meadows Realty, Inc. includes the name of the listing brokers. Listing broker has attempted to offer accurate data, but buyers are advised to confirm all items. Information last updated on 7/15/2024.